Germany expecting breakthrough on EU migration rules as ministers hold talks in Brussels – Europe live | Europe

Germany moves on migration crisis regulation amid domestic pressure

Kate Connolly

The German government appears to have given up its blockage of the long-disputed crisis regulation over asylum seekers which forms a key part of the meeting of EU migration ministers in Brussels today.

The bloc is seeking to find agreement on a mechanism to fairly distribute asylum seekers arriving in the bloc outside of regular border posts.

Germany’s interior minister Nancy Faeser has said she now expects a breakthrough.

Chancellor Olaf Scholz also showed optimism, telling the economic weekly ‘Wirtschaftswoche’: “We will pass the new common European asylum system legislation which will provide a solidarity mechanism for the intake and distribution of refugees.”

The Green party’s opposition to the core part of the reform had until Wednesday been the cause of the government’s failure to throw its weight behind it. The party’s concern is that in times of crisis protection standards for migrants would be inadequate under the new rules.

But Scholz took the executive decision at a cabinet meeting on Wednesday that the mechanism could no longer be blocked, using the rarely applied ‘Machtwort’ –exercising his authority as head of government, and thus paving the way for Faeser to head to Brussels in a negotiating capacity rather than in what would likely have been interpreted as an obstructive mode.

Annalena Baerbock, the foreign minister and leading Green, welcomed the development, saying: “finally Brussels can negotiate properly”.

Christian Dürr of the pro-business FDP, part of the coalition, praised Scholz’s “decisive action”, adding that “we now have a unique chance to better manage migration, a chance which we cannot waste”.

There is a sense of urgency over the matter in Germany, with the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees having registered more than 204,000 first-time asylum applicants this year, until the end of August, an increase on 77% in comparison to the same period last year.

This does not include the more than one million refugees from Ukraine who have fled to Germany, who are not required to apply for asylum.

The issue is high on the agenda of several looming state and local elections and seen as one of the main reasons for a soar in the far-right populist AfD’s poll ratings.

German Interior Minister Nancy Faeser (R) and Austrian Interior Minister Gerhard Karner speak with each other at the start of a Justice and Home Affairs Council (Home Affairs) meeting in Brussels, Belgium, 28 September 2023 . EPA/OLIVIER HOSLET
German Interior Minister Nancy Faeser (R) and Austrian Interior Minister Gerhard Karner speak with each other at the start of a Justice and Home Affairs Council (Home Affairs) meeting in Brussels, Belgium, 28 September 2023 . EPA/OLIVIER HOSLET Photograph: Olivier Hoslet/EPA

Key events

Poland opposed to migration crisis rules, ambassador says

Poland’s ambassador to the EU, Andrzej Sadoś, told the Guardian today that Warsaw “is refusing to accept any elements of mandatory relocation, the distribution of some mandatory quotas” and is also opposed “to any obligatory payment for not accepting migrants.”

EU countries, he wrote in response to a question, “should have full discretion in choosing between different type of solidarity measures.”

“In our opinion, the instrument in proposed form does not adequately respond to crisis, force majeure and, above all, the instrumentalisation of migration,” the Polish ambassador said, adding that “the crisis regulation does not ensure the right balance between solidarity and responsibility.”

Permanent Representative of Poland to the European Union Andrzej Sados attends a roundtable prior to the plenary session of the EU ministers for defence in Toledo, Spain August 30, 2023. REUTERS/Isabel Infantes
Permanent Representative of Poland to the European Union Andrzej Sados attends a roundtable prior to the plenary session of the EU ministers for defence in Toledo, Spain August 30, 2023. REUTERS/Isabel Infantes Photograph: Isabel Infantes/Reuters

Talks continue as ministers seek compromise

Commissioner Ylva Johansson held talks with German interior minister Nancy Faeser in Brussels as officials race to seal a compromise on a migration crisis regulation.

Discussions with 🇩🇪 Minister of Interior @NancyFaeser.
We agree on importance of reaching a final agreement on the crisis proposal, which will bring us one step closer to finalising the Pact.

Thank you Nancy for your pragmatic and constructive approach.#MigrationEU

— Ylva Johansson (@YlvaJohansson) September 28, 2023

Germany moves on migration crisis regulation amid domestic pressure

Germany expecting breakthrough on EU migration rules as ministers hold talks in Brussels – Europe live | Europe

Kate Connolly

The German government appears to have given up its blockage of the long-disputed crisis regulation over asylum seekers which forms a key part of the meeting of EU migration ministers in Brussels today.

The bloc is seeking to find agreement on a mechanism to fairly distribute asylum seekers arriving in the bloc outside of regular border posts.

Germany’s interior minister Nancy Faeser has said she now expects a breakthrough.

Chancellor Olaf Scholz also showed optimism, telling the economic weekly ‘Wirtschaftswoche’: “We will pass the new common European asylum system legislation which will provide a solidarity mechanism for the intake and distribution of refugees.”

The Green party’s opposition to the core part of the reform had until Wednesday been the cause of the government’s failure to throw its weight behind it. The party’s concern is that in times of crisis protection standards for migrants would be inadequate under the new rules.

But Scholz took the executive decision at a cabinet meeting on Wednesday that the mechanism could no longer be blocked, using the rarely applied ‘Machtwort’ –exercising his authority as head of government, and thus paving the way for Faeser to head to Brussels in a negotiating capacity rather than in what would likely have been interpreted as an obstructive mode.

Annalena Baerbock, the foreign minister and leading Green, welcomed the development, saying: “finally Brussels can negotiate properly”.

Christian Dürr of the pro-business FDP, part of the coalition, praised Scholz’s “decisive action”, adding that “we now have a unique chance to better manage migration, a chance which we cannot waste”.

There is a sense of urgency over the matter in Germany, with the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees having registered more than 204,000 first-time asylum applicants this year, until the end of August, an increase on 77% in comparison to the same period last year.

This does not include the more than one million refugees from Ukraine who have fled to Germany, who are not required to apply for asylum.

The issue is high on the agenda of several looming state and local elections and seen as one of the main reasons for a soar in the far-right populist AfD’s poll ratings.

German Interior Minister Nancy Faeser (R) and Austrian Interior Minister Gerhard Karner speak with each other at the start of a Justice and Home Affairs Council (Home Affairs) meeting in Brussels, Belgium, 28 September 2023 . EPA/OLIVIER HOSLET
German Interior Minister Nancy Faeser (R) and Austrian Interior Minister Gerhard Karner speak with each other at the start of a Justice and Home Affairs Council (Home Affairs) meeting in Brussels, Belgium, 28 September 2023 . EPA/OLIVIER HOSLET Photograph: Olivier Hoslet/EPA

Migration reform ‘really urgent’, Belgian politician says

Nicole De Moor, Belgium’s state secretary for asylum and migration, said ahead of an EU ministers’ session today that “it’s an important day for Europe” and that the situation in many European countries “shows that the reform of Europe’s migration policy and asylum policy is really urgent – but we are on the right way and the right direction.”

The state secretary state said that progress has been made and that she is “confident” ministers can reach an agreement on a new migration crisis mechanism.

“We have to make progress in our relationships with third countries – countries of origin and transit countries – to invest in those countries, in economic opportunities, education, to offer people opportunities in those countries, and in the same time to cooperate with those countries on border management and on return.”

Asked about a controversial EU deal with Tunisia, the Belgian politician said the memorandum of understanding with the country is “an important step” and an “investment” in addressing root causes of migration.

“I think this is really the way we should continue, and make agreements with other countries as well,” she added.

Belgium State Secretary for Asylum and Migration policy Nicole de Moor speaks during a press conference following the Minister's council meeting of the Federal Government, in Brussels on September 15, 2023. (Photo by JAMES ARTHUR GEKIERE / Belga / AFP) / Belgium OUT (Photo by JAMES ARTHUR GEKIERE/Belga/AFP via Getty Images)
Belgium State Secretary for Asylum and Migration policy Nicole de Moor speaks during a press conference following the Minister’s council meeting of the Federal Government, in Brussels on September 15, 2023. (Photo by JAMES ARTHUR GEKIERE / Belga / AFP) / Belgium OUT (Photo by JAMES ARTHUR GEKIERE/Belga/AFP via Getty Images) Photograph: James Arthur Gekiere/Belga/AFP/Getty Images

Ireland hopes for migration deal today, minister says

Irish justice minister Helen McEntee said this morning that she hopes EU countries reach an agreement today on new crisis rules for significant surges in the number of migrants arriving in Europe.

Speaking to reporters ahead of a ministers’ meeting in Brussels today, McEntee said that “this has obviously been a long, ongoing negotiation among member states, it’s so important that we do reach a conclusion before the end of this current session.”

Discussions today on what Europe can do on the root causes of migration is an area which “from Ireland’s point of view, we have been particularly keen to try and address.”

Asked if Ireland will fully participate in the EU’s new migration and asylum pact if it’s agreed, the minister said: “we will participate in whatever way we can, yes.”

Justice minister Helen McEntee speaks to the media at the Association of Garda Superintendents conference at Killashee House in Naas, Co Kildare. Picture date: Wednesday September 13, 2023. PA Photo. See PA story IRISH Garda. Photo credit should read: Brian Lawless/PA Wire
Justice minister Helen McEntee speaks to the media at the Association of Garda Superintendents conference at Killashee House in Naas, Co Kildare. Picture date: Wednesday September 13, 2023. PA Photo. Photo credit: Brian Lawless/PA Wire Photograph: Brian Lawless/PA

Lisa O'Carroll

Lisa O’Carroll

On today’s agenda

Migration will remain one of the hottest topics on the agenda, diplomats have said ahead of a key meeting of EU interior ministers today.

Today they will get a full briefing from the European Commission on the controversial €167m deal with Tunisia to stem irregular migration from the north African country to Italy.

They are also expected to reach agreement on a new law to create rules in the event of a repeat of the 2015/2016 crisis when more than 1m refugees came to the EU from Syria and beyond.

This follows agreement from Germany on a new text. Along with Ireland and Luxembourg, it had reservations about the rules governing unaccompanied minors.

The ministers will also open a discussion on the question of permanent residence for up to 4m Ukrainian refugees.

They are likely to agree a commission proposal to extend the existing temporary protection directive to 2025 but ministers are keen to start the discussion for what happens beyond that working on the assumption that many of the 4m Ukrainian refugees may make the EU their home.

Given Ukraine’s desire to join the EU it may also be a route into a wider discussion about freedom of movement, diplomats say.

We need to deprive populists from argument that Europe cannot sort migration, senior EU official says

Lisa O'Carroll

Lisa O’Carroll

The EU is on the cusp of completing its package of new migration laws after Germany agreed to new rules in the event of a sudden surge in migration from a country in crisis, the commissioner responsible for co-ordinating the work on the new regime has said.

EU member states have already agreed new rules on asylum procedures and “solidarity” relocation of irregular migrants converging on frontline countries such as Italy, but they are now looking for a legal framework to deal with crises such as 2015/2016 when more than 1m refugees came from Syria and beyond.

“We are very encouraged by the progress made,” said Margaritis Schinas, the commissioner responsible for coordinating the package.

“And we hope that the ministers will agree today one of the on one of the most important remaining aspects of the overall reform, the crisis regulation,” said Schinas, a Greek centre-right politician who is a vice president of the European Commission.

“If this happens, then we’ll have a window of opportunity to obtain the overall agreement before the European election of next year,” he said, adding: “We need to deprive the demagogues and populists from the argument that Europe cannot sort out our migration problem.”

Vice President of the European Commission Margaritis Schinas attends a press conference during the European informal meeting on Education and Youth, in Zaragoza, Spain, 19 September 2023. EPA/JAVIER CEBOLLADA
Vice President of the European Commission Margaritis Schinas attends a press conference during the European informal meeting on Education and Youth, in Zaragoza, Spain, 19 September 2023. EPA/JAVIER CEBOLLADA Photograph: Javier Cebollada/EPA

Africans tell of being forced into the desert at Tunisia border

Lorenzo Tondo

Lorenzo Tondo

Migrants from sub-Saharan Africa have spoken of their horror at being forcibly returned to remote desert regions where some have died of thirst as they attempt to cross the border into Tunisia.

After the European Union agreed to a €1bn (£870m) migration deal with Tunisia, human rights groups are urging Brussels to take a tougher line on allegations that Tunisian authorities have been pushing people back to deserted border areas, often with fatal results.

According to an official from a major intergovernmental organisation, Tunisian authorities relocated more than 4,000 people in July alone to military buffer zones at the borders with Libya and Algeria.

“About 1,200 people were pushed back to the Libyan border in the first week of July alone,” said the source, who was speaking on condition of anonymity. By late August, the source added, their organisation knew of seven people who had died of thirst after being pushed back.

An NGO working with refugees puts the estimate at between 50 and 70. The Guardian could not independently verify the figure.

“In early July, the Tunisian police captured us in Sfax,’’ said Salma, a 28-year-old Nigerian woman. “My two-year-old son and I were taken by some policemen and pushed back into the desert at the Libyan border. My husband was captured by other border guards and I don’t know what happened to him. I haven’t heard from him since then because while they were pushing us back I lost my phone.’’

Read the full story here.

Salma, a 28-year-old Nigerian woman with his son camping in front of OIM office in Tunis.
Salma, a 28-year-old Nigerian woman with her son camping in front of OIM office in Tunis. Photograph: Alessio Mamo/The Guardian

EU ‘making progress’ on new migration crisis rules, commissioner says

The EU’s commissioner for home affairs Ylva Johansson said this morning that “we are making progress” and she is “optimistic” that European government can reach an agreement today on a proposal for crisis rules in cases when Europe experiences a large surge in the number of migrant arrivals.

Speaking to reporters ahead of a ministers’ meeting in Brussels, Johansson pointed out that the crisis regulation is the “last piece” of the EU’s proposed new pact on asylum and migration.

Ylva Johansson.
Ylva Johansson. Photograph: Raquel Manzanares/EPA

Welcome to the blog

Good morning and welcome back to the Europe live blog, which comes to you today from the EU Council in Brussels, where ministers from across the continent are discussing migration this morning.

Ministers will get an update on a controversial deal between the EU and Tunisia, and there are signals the EU’s member states are close to an agreement on the thorny issue of rules in case of a migration crisis.

The session comes at a time when Italy is stepping up its crackdown on migrants, and after Germany introduced border checks with Poland and the Czech Republic.

Throughout the day we will be delving into the ministers’ debates, as well as all the latest news and analysis on this issue from across the region.

Send your comments to [email protected].

Leave a reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here